Research4 min

Card sorting in UX: how to run it and read the results

A practical card sorting guide: open vs closed vs hybrid sorts, how many participants you need, remote tools, and how to turn results into navigation.

Saurabh YadavFounder, Design Studio by Saurabh
ResearchCard sortingInformation architectureNavigation
Share

If people can't find something, it might as well not exist. Card sorting is the simplest research method for making sure your navigation and content groups match how users think, not how your org chart looks.

What card sorting is

In a card sort, participants group a set of topics (the "cards") into categories that make sense to them. You learn which items belong together in users' minds and what they'd call those groups.

It's one of the core methods in information architecture, alongside tree testing.

Open, closed or hybrid?

TypeHow it worksUse it when
OpenParticipants create and name their own groupsYou're designing navigation from scratch
ClosedParticipants sort cards into groups you defineYou're testing an existing or proposed structure
HybridYour groups, but participants can add new onesYou have a draft but want to find gaps

Start open when you're exploring. Use closed when you want to check a structure.

How to run a card sort

1. Choose the cards

Pick 30 to 60 items that represent your real content: features, product categories, help topics. Fewer and you won't see patterns; more and people get tired.

  • Write cards in plain language users understand.
  • Avoid cards that share an obvious word ("Account settings", "Account history"), or people will group by the word, not the meaning.

2. Recruit participants

For quantitative patterns in an online sort, aim for around 15 to 20 participants per user group. For an in-person, think-aloud sort, even 5 to 8 people give rich insight into why they group things.

3. Run it

Remote tools like OptimalSort or Maze handle the sorting and analysis. In person, paper cards on a table work beautifully, and you get to hear the reasoning.

Tip

In moderated sessions, ask participants to think aloud. "I'd expect refunds under Orders, not Help, because it's about my order" is worth more than any chart.

4. Analyse the results

  • Similarity matrix: shows how often each pair of cards was grouped together. Strong clusters are your natural categories.
  • Dendrogram: a tree view of the clusters, useful for deciding how many top-level groups to have.
  • Group names: look at the labels people used. They're often better than the ones your team picked.

5. Turn insight into structure

Draft a navigation from the strongest clusters, then validate it with a tree test, where users try to find specific items in a text-only version of your structure.

Common card sorting mistakes

MistakeFix
Using internal jargon on cardsWrite cards in customers' words
Too many cardsKeep it under about 60
Treating results as the final answerValidate with tree testing
Mixing very different user groupsAnalyse groups separately

Note

Card sorting tells you how people group content. It doesn't tell you whether they can find things in your actual interface. That's what tree testing and usability testing are for.

Work with us

Need research done for you? Our UX research and usability testing services cover interviews, surveys and usability tests, with clear recommendations.

FAQ

What is card sorting in UX?

Card sorting is a research method where participants group topics or features into categories that make sense to them. It helps designers build navigation and information architecture that match how users think.

How many participants do you need for card sorting?

For an online, quantitative card sort, around 15 to 20 participants per user group usually shows clear patterns. For moderated, think-aloud sessions, 5 to 8 participants can give rich qualitative insight.

What is the difference between open and closed card sorting?

In an open card sort, participants create and name their own groups. In a closed card sort, they sort cards into categories you provide. Open sorts help you discover structure; closed sorts help you test it.

Key takeaways

  • Card sorting shows how users group and name your content.
  • Use open sorts to explore and closed sorts to validate.
  • 30 to 60 plain-language cards and 15 to 20 participants is a good starting point.
  • Read similarity matrices and users' own group names.
  • Always validate the resulting structure with a tree test.

What to do next

List the top 40 things users come to your product to do and run a quick open sort with five customers. If your navigation needs a proper rethink, we can help.

Saurabh Yadav's Memoji

Written by

Saurabh Yadav

Founder of Design Studio by Saurabh, a UI/UX design studio in India. We design apps and websites that feel effortless, from research to shipped pixels. Most recently: Pukaar.ai, as seen on Shark Tank India, and the Demerara Bank app.

Keep reading

All articles →